How to Evaluate Any Youth Leadership Curriculum Through a Values-Based Lens

The first hurdle, for you as a buyer, is the beautiful brochure. You have seen dozens of sales pitches, but how can you determine from that pretty front cover what your students will actually get from that curriculum? Something that will enrich their character and not just pay lip service to the idea of leadership in the name of a skills workshop. To cut through the fluff, you need a few evaluative questions or a rubric to help you decide if what is in front of you is a real values-based youth leadership curriculum or not.

But here’s the good news! Character is the foundation of leadership and a real character-based youth leadership curriculum will always have it as a focus. Here are six questions in order of priority to ask yourself as you try to differentiate a values-based youth leadership curriculum from just another youth leadership skills-building curriculum in your next purchasing decision.

Does it teach character before competency?

Ask to see the scope and sequence of the curriculum. Does it focus on developing character, integrity, and empathy as the basis of leadership or is it light on those important areas in favor of teaching communication and goal setting skills? A values-based youth leadership curriculum will indicate places in the lesson plans where those character traits are explicitly taught, modeled, and emphasized. It should highlight those areas as integral parts of the whole program and not as add-ons at either the beginning or the end of the program.

How is leadership defined as influence rather than position?

Many traditional leadership programs make the mistake of defining leadership as a position or the desire to attain a position of power or authority. Leadership, at its root, is influence, not position. A values-based youth leadership curriculum goes one step further by defining leadership as the ability to influence others, even in the absence of a position of authority. The curriculum provider is then asked to define leadership in his or her own words. If he or she cannot do that without referring to a position, then you know immediately that this is not a values-based youth leadership curriculum.

Are students modeling and influencing their peers?

Ask to see the methodology or design section of the curriculum. Is the focus on peer-to-peer modeling and discussion where students influence each other? This is another sure sign of a values-based youth leadership curriculum. Is the instructor simply a facilitator of discussion, or is he or she talking to students, lecturing them?

Is it really for everyone, or just the self-selected few?

Ask if the program is embedded in the core curriculum of the school or if it is an elective or self-chosen unit or lesson. Most values-based youth leadership programs are designed for universal participation rather than self-selection. It may be a program that is woven throughout the core curriculum, so that all students participate. This is in contrast to a program which is only open to those few students who have self-selected for leadership training, such as an elective unit of study that appears in the school catalog. It is a program that reaches into the classroom, not one that is selected by that self-appointed “elite” group of students that even the principal doesn’t suspect (and certainly not expect) to have leadership qualities someday soon.

Can you actually have a complete youth leadership program, or will you get a single unit or weekend retreat?

Many youth leadership programs begin with a single unit or weekend retreat that gets students excited and then expect them to continue the program on their own. Ask to see the pacing guide to determine if the curriculum has a series of units that roll up to a youth leadership program or if it is simply an isolated lesson. A multi-year program, or one that spans the entire school year, is more likely to demonstrate commitment to developing leadership competencies in the students.

Is your program able to highlight multi-year experience or even multiple populations served?

Any program can cite the great results they saw in year one, but ask them to show you evidence of the program’s success in multiple populations. When rolling out a new program in your school, ask them if the program has been successful in other schools (or populations) and how many. When inquiring about experience, ask them how long the program has been in existence or in use. The principal of a school in Kigali recently implemented a values-based youth leadership program in his school for five years now (having trained over three thousand students). He is about to graduate a whole class of students who have been through the program, but he knows that he has not developed leaders; he has developed a whole generation of young people who understand the value of character. A successful values-based youth leadership program will demonstrate this ability to highlight impact and experience for you as well.

Scoring Your Youth Leadership Curriculum Purchasing Options

Now that you have the questions, go back and score your options using these criteria. If the curriculum options you are considering can answer these questions with enthusiasm and ease, then you know that it is the right fit for your school. If not, you can safely move on in your search for the right curriculum for your students.

When considering youth leadership curriculum, always err on the side of caution when thinking through your selection criteria. After all, you are going to be using what you choose for years to come, and we know you will be working with more than a few students when you do. It’s not just about the money. It’s about investing in your students’ characters and building the leadership competencies they need from the ground up, starting with values, not simply the surface skills. And bring this rubric along to your next leadership team faculty meeting, having your teachers review the ideas independently before coming together to talk through it. You’ll be surprised how helpful multiple sets of eyes can be when evaluating a youth leadership curriculum and how much faster it is for you to spot the cracks in any given option.

The right rubric can make all the difference when choosing a youth leadership curriculum, and this guide can help you sort out the difference between a values-based program that pays only lip service to leadership versus one that actually takes a values-based approach. That’s the Maxwell Leadership Foundation’s iLead program, now implemented in more than 170 countries for K-12 students, and it’s one way to learn how Maxwell Leadership utilizes a values-based approach to youth leadership development. We invite you to learn more about iLead and Maxwell Leadership’s values-based approach at maxwellleadership.org.

“The most powerful ripple in any room belongs to the person who chooses to serve, not the person who is seen.”

— John C. Maxwell, Founder

What We Learned in Paraguay

In 2014, when we began our partnership with the government of Paraguay, we made an assumption most organizations make: change flows from the top down. Get the president on board, get the ministers trained, and the rest follows by institutional gravity.
But the change that endured — measured five years later in institutional culture surveys — came disproportionately from the mid-level: school principals who quietly changed their staff meetings, department heads who started their Monday briefings with a question instead of an announcement.
47K+
Leaders Trained in Paraguay
5 yr
Duration of Partnership
83%
Report Culture Shift in Their Team

The Stage Is a Microphone, Not a Generator

This is the core misunderstanding of how influence works. Most of us believe leadership influence flows like a broadcast signal: the more prominent the speaker, the more powerful the signal.

But influence doesn’t work like a broadcast. It works like a ripple. Ripples are generated by contact — by the specific, personal, relational moment in which one person’s character touches another’s.

Mark Cole

CEO, Maxwell Leadership Foundation
Mark leads the Foundation’s global strategy and has spent 25 years working alongside John C. Maxwell to bring transformational leadership to nations worldwide.
Keep Reading

More Ripples Worth Reading

A values-based youth leadership curriculum shapes character, not just performance, forming adults who lead with integrity for decades. Here’s why
Discover the relational and reflective skills a student leadership roundtable curriculum builds, outcomes no lecture, textbook, or test can replicate.
Not all leadership programs are equal. See the design differences that make a values-based youth leadership curriculum built to last,
Your Ripple Is Waiting

The Room You're In Is
the Right Room to Start

You don’t need a bigger audience or a more prominent role. You need the person in front of you, and a decision to lead them well.